- Linux Computers
- DVDs & Films
- Writings & Reports
- Arab Spring
- Libyan Revolution
- Libyans spilled blood for us!
- NATO killed 60 civilians in Libya
- ANSWER Libya Forum
- Battle to Liberate Tripoli
- Behind the Green Curtain
- NATO's Game Plan in Libya
- How They Won
- Abdul Fattah Younis
- Abdul Rahman
- Amy gets it wrong
- CCDS on Libya
- Chris Hedges on Libya
- Current Events in Libya
- Doha summit
- Racism in Libya
- On Libya & Glenn Greenwald
- NATO's intervention in Libya
- Gilbert Achcar on Libya
- Tripoli's Long Night
- Green Sq Reality Check
- Qaddafi's Million Man March
- Lockerbie Bomber Lie
- Kucinich & Qaddafi Regime
- NATO over Tripoli
- Libya & Syria: Dueling Rallies
- AI on Libya again
- Situation in Libya
- ANSWER answers me
- Libya in the news today
- Tripoli Burn Notice
- Libya on PressTV
- Throwing babies out
- Libyans killed by NATO
- Libyans, Palestinians & Israelis
- Africa Rising
- The Occupy Movement
- The Year in Review
- Occupy Oakland on Jan. 28
- How Occupy LA got itself evicted
- Why Villaraigosa kicked us out
- Demonization of Mario
- Was DHS behind the eviction
- OccupyLA Eviction
- Did 1st Amend protect OLA
- Bandits of America
- OccupyLA Day 48
- Hard Block Cafe
- 10K March with OccupyLA
- OccupyLA - Day 8
- OccupyLA - Day 7
- OccupyLA - Day 6
- OccupyLA - Day 5
- OccupyLA - Day 4
- OccupyLA – Day 3
- OccupyLA - Day 2
- OccupyLA - Day 1
- Occupy Los Angeles Starts
- Arab Spring Comes to LA
- OccupyLA on 10/1
- G20 Road Trip
- The Decisive Decade
- Anonymous & WikiLeaks
- US Wars
- Why the US didn't find WMD
- US troops pose with bodies
- Haditha & USMC
- Louis Proyect reviews VAH
- Announcing Premiere of VAH
- Vietnam War was holocaust
- What Is A Holocaust?
- Winter Soldier Southwest
- Ex-Marine Corps Serial Killer
- Another Day In Iraq
- The Liberation of Viet Nam
- Hearing Cpl. Ryan
- Ahmadinejad @ Columbia
- Executing Afghan Kids
- How War Started
- Agent Orange in Iraq
- US Killing in Yemen
- Happy New Years Iraq!
- US Politics
- Too Big To Fail?
- Liberty Bell Destroyed!
- Xmas Carol for Obama
- Obama on Vietnam
- Stop This Oil Leak
- Karl Marx on TV!
- BP Dome won't work
- Rick Santorum
- Bill Clinton Rips GOP
- Laid off Census Worker
- Severe Conservative?
- This Week: Sen. John McCain
- Newspaper Death Spiral
- Sarah Palin
- Sotomayor Experience
- "Everyone is Disapearing"
- Racism in the US
- Internet Freedom & Open Source
- My Best Tweets
- Android make Google Money?
- Country Codes for the Internet?
- End of the Internet
- Free Press would this Illegal!
- Free Press Agenda?
- Google Verizon Deal
- Keith Olbermann's Deception
- Obama versus Google
- What are these RMT Alerts?
- Verizon's Rebate Challenge
- Victory is Sweet
- Why I like Google
- Would Net Neutrality Stop WikiLeaks?
- e- G8 plans for Internet
- Al Franken on Network Neutrality
- Cyber War Report
- FCC Internet Rules
- Google Must Be Evil
- Google\Verizon Net Neutrality
- Internet Engineers
- Julian Assange on Threat
- Let a 100 Websites Blossom
- Mountain comes to Mohammad
- Net Neutrality's Trojan Horse
- Obama's Internet Coup d'état
- Victory on Internet Censorship
- Daily Kos Diaries
- Stubborn Things
- WL Central Writings
Obama on Vietnam
From President Obama's speech tonight annoucing his escalation of the War in Afghanistan. Obabma's comment are in bold
There are those who suggest that Afghanistan is another Vietnam
Forgive me if I take that comment personally but I do feel a need to respond.
Yet this argument depends upon a false reading of history.
Well, let's see. Obama gives three reading of history that he believes highlights the differences:
Unlike Vietnam, we are joined by a broad coalition of 43 nations that recognizes the legitimacy of our action.
Obama is right to say that we didn't have 43 countries with us then but for the Vietnam War the U.S. also Kabuled together a "coalition of the willing" including South Korea, Kingdom of Laos, Australia, New Zealand, Canada, the Republic of China, the Philippines, Thailand, Spain (13 soldier), Nicaragua and Paraguay (offered to send troops). At the time it was painted as an "international"effort to stop communism, but in hindsight it is clear that the Vietnamese had it right when they named it "the American War." Afghanistan is a "NATO" [North Atlantic Treaty Organization] operation, Vietnam was a SEATO [South East Asia Treaty Organization] operation. The difference is as clear as mud.
Unlike Vietnam, we are not facing a broad-based popular insurgency.
Again hindsight is 20/20 but at the time nobody in the government said the U.S. was fighting "a broad-based popular insurgency." At the time the U.S. completely denied that Vietnamese communist had popular support. They were branded terrorists and it was claimed that they only gained support and recruites through terror and intimidation like they say the Taliban does now. The real reason Obama needs to since 30,000 more troops to Afghanistan after 8 years of war has nothing to do with broad-base popular opposition to our occupation. If you think that you must be confused. And most importantly...
And most importantly, unlike Vietnam, the American people were viciously attacked from Afghanistan.
Has he forgotten about the Gulf of Tonkin Incident already ? Has he forgotten that on August 5, 1964 President Johnson said "Last night I announced to the American people that the North Vietnamese regime had conducted further deliberate attacks against U.S. naval vessels operating in international waters." And this attack was used to pass what amounted to a declaration of war on Vietnam. Of course, years later even the Navy was forced to admit that "There was actually no North Vietnamese attack that night." With hindsight we now know that the Tonkin Gulf Incident was an "inside job" , a false excuse for war, not like 911. Clearly that was launched from Afghanistan. Right!
Given that President Obama felt compelled to speak at length of this 40 year old conflict, and these are the three differences he chose to highlight, I think he needs to re-read his history, and if he doesn't have much time for reading these days, I've got a film he can watch. Vietnam: American Holocaust.
- Printer-friendly version
- Login or register to post comments